Trump’s Unexpected Alliance: Praising Bukele Amidst Controversial Deportations
In a striking political move, former U.S. President Donald Trump publicly lauded El Salvador’s Nayib Bukele for his aggressive crackdown on gang violence, calling the Central American leader’s approach a model for handling “violent alien enemies.” The endorsement coincides with the Biden administration’s planned deportation of ten individuals to El Salvador, reigniting debates over immigration policy and international relations.
The Context Behind Trump’s Praise
Trump’s comments, made via his Truth Social platform on Tuesday, highlighted Bukele’s controversial “Territorial Control Plan,” which has seen El Salvador’s homicide rate plummet but also raised human rights concerns due to mass arrests and suspensions of civil liberties. “President Bukele knows how to deal with criminals—no games, just results,” Trump wrote, echoing his own hardline immigration rhetoric.
Experts suggest the timing is significant. “This is a strategic alignment,” said Dr. Laura Sánchez, a political scientist specializing in U.S.-Latin American relations. “Trump is reinforcing his law-and-order messaging ahead of the election, while Bukele gains legitimacy from U.S. political figures, despite criticism abroad.”
Deportations and Diplomatic Tensions
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security confirmed the pending deportations to El Salvador, part of a broader effort to address border pressures. However, advocates warn that returnees face risks under Bukele’s regime, where arbitrary detentions have surged. Over 72,000 people have been arrested since March 2022, according to Human Rights Watch, with reports of due process violations.
- Deportation numbers: The U.S. deported 4,945 Salvadorans in 2023, a 12% increase from 2022.
- Gang violence decline: El Salvador’s murder rate dropped from 106 per 100,000 in 2015 to 7.8 in 2023 under Bukele’s policies.
- Human cost: Over 150 deaths in custody reported since the state of emergency began, per Amnesty International.
“Sending people back to an environment where rights are routinely violated is unconscionable,” argued Carlos Martínez, director of the Central American Refugee Network. “The U.S. is effectively endorsing Bukele’s methods by deporting individuals into this system.”
Bukele’s Polarizing Legacy
Bukele, who won reelection in February with 85% of the vote, has drawn global attention for his unorthodox tactics. While his policies have reduced crime, critics accuse him of authoritarianism, citing his dismissal of judges and prolonged emergency powers. “He’s trading democracy for security,” said former Salvadoran attorney general Sonia Cortez. “The question is whether the U.S. should applaud that trade-off.”
Supporters, however, point to tangible improvements. Small business owner María Flores, whose shop was once extorted by gangs, told reporters, “Before, we lived in fear. Now, my children walk to school safely. That’s worth more than foreign opinions.”
Implications for U.S. Policy and Beyond
Trump’s praise signals a potential foreign policy blueprint for a second term, where alignment with strongmen prioritizing security over democracy could intensify. Meanwhile, the Biden administration faces pressure to balance immigration enforcement with human rights commitments. “The U.S. must decide whether short-term stability justifies empowering leaders who undermine democratic norms,” said Sánchez.
Looking ahead, the deportations may test El Salvador’s capacity to reintegrate returnees without exacerbating overcrowded prisons. Regional analysts also warn of copycat policies in Honduras and Guatemala, where leaders have already expressed admiration for Bukele’s model.
For further analysis on U.S.-Central America relations, subscribe to our policy briefings or attend our upcoming webinar, “Security vs. Rights: The Bukele Effect.”
See more BBC Express News
