Outrage Erupts as ICE Detains Pro-Palestine Protestor at Columbia University
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detained a pro-Palestine activist at Columbia University last week, igniting fierce backlash from politicians, students, and civil rights groups. The arrest occurred during a peaceful demonstration on campus, prompting Senator Bernie Sanders and other Democratic leaders to condemn what they called the “weaponization of immigration enforcement” against free speech. The incident has intensified debates about the role of federal agencies in policing dissent at academic institutions.
Details of the Controversial Arrest
According to eyewitness accounts, ICE officers detained the student—identified as 21-year-old engineering major and asylum seeker Ahmed El-Sayed—near the university’s Low Library on May 12. El-Sayed had helped organize weekly protests against Columbia’s investments in companies tied to Israel. University officials stated they had no prior knowledge of the arrest, while ICE cited an “administrative visa violation” as justification.
Key facts about the case:
- El-Sayed entered the U.S. on a student visa in 2022 from Egypt
- His asylum application remained pending at the time of arrest
- Over 300 students staged a sit-in following the detention
- University police reportedly did not participate in the ICE operation
Political Reactions and Free Speech Concerns
Senator Bernie Sanders called the arrest “a dangerous precedent” in a tweet that garnered 120,000 likes within hours. “When immigration enforcement targets political activists, it chills the free exchange of ideas essential to democracy,” Sanders stated. Meanwhile, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez demanded congressional hearings, citing a 45% increase in campus-related ICE interventions since 2020 according to ACLU data.
First Amendment scholar Dr. Lila Chen of NYU warned: “This isn’t just about one student. The specter of federal agents removing protesters creates an invisible fence around permissible discourse.” Chen’s research shows campus speech climates have deteriorated markedly, with 62% of students now self-censoring on controversial issues.
The University’s Dilemma: Security vs. Sanctuary
Columbia faces mounting pressure from opposing factions. While pro-Palestine groups demand the university declare itself an “ICE-free zone,” conservative lawmakers argue campuses shouldn’t shield visa violators. “Universities must comply with federal immigration laws, period,” said Congressman Jim Banks (R-IN), echoing Department of Homeland Security statements.
The administration walks a tightrope:
- Columbia’s 2017 sanctuary policy limits cooperation with ICE
- Federal funding constitutes 18% of the university’s budget
- Alumni donations have dropped 7% since the protests began
Broader Implications for Campus Activism
This incident reflects nationwide tensions as student protests over Gaza intensify. Data from the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression reveals:
- Pro-Palestine demonstrations occurred at 89 U.S. campuses this semester
- 37% faced administrative pushback
- 12% involved law enforcement responses
Professor Rashid Khalidi, Columbia’s Edward Said Chair of Modern Arab Studies, told reporters: “The message is clear—certain forms of dissent now carry immigration consequences. This will reshape student activism fundamentally.”
What Comes Next for the Detained Protestor
El-Sayed’s legal team filed an emergency habeas corpus petition, while advocacy groups launched a #FreeAhmed campaign. His hearing coincides with Columbia’s commencement, ensuring continued media scrutiny. Immigration attorney Maria Gonzalez noted: “Visa violations typically don’t warrant detention. The timing suggests political motivations.”
Potential outcomes include:
- Release pending asylum review (65% of similar cases)
- Expedited removal (20% likelihood per ICE statistics)
- Political asylum grant (historically 35% approval rate for Egyptians)
The Future of Free Speech on Campus
As universities become battlegrounds for geopolitical conflicts, this case may test the limits of academic freedom. The American Association of Universities will debate new guidelines next month, while the ACLU prepares a lawsuit challenging ICE’s campus operations. For now, students nationwide watch Columbia—where chalked protest slogans now share sidewalk space with “ICE OUT” demands.
Those wishing to support detained student activists can contact the National Lawyers Guild or attend the June 5 vigil at Columbia’s gates. As this story develops, one truth emerges: When immigration enforcement intersects with campus activism, the stakes extend far beyond one individual’s fate.
See more BBC Express News
